Rubin on Situation of IDPs in Iraqi Kurdistan

Banasiaw Dispatch
Michael Rubin
The New Republic
July 23, 2001

When Americans think ethnic cleansing, they think of Bosnia, Kosovo, Rwanda. They don’t
think of Iraq. But that’s because most Americans don’t go to places like Banasiaw, a
checkpoint along the border between the U.S.-patrolled safe haven in northern Iraq and
Saddam Hussein’s distinctly unsafe terrain to the south. In Banasiaw, the ethnically
cleansed-Iraqi Kurds, Turkmans, and other non-Arabs forced from their homes by Saddam’s
men-constitute a brisk traffic. “We had two expelled families arrive just today,” says a
Kurdish commander named Jamal. Two families today. Another four tomorrow. They’ve
been coming for years. According to the U.S. Committee on Refugees, the number of
internally displaced persons in northern Iraq increased from around 640,000 in 1994 to
almost one million in 1999. And thousands more are expelled every year.

Saddam’s ethnic cleansing isn’t new. In fact, he was once famous for it. In 1988, during the
Iran-Iraq War, Saddam’s forces carried out the infamous Anfal Campaign-razing some
5,000 villages in northern Iraq, relocating populations into well-guarded “collective towns,”
and using chemical weapons against those who did not move fast enough. By the end of the
year, approximately 182,000 non-Arabs had been massacred. But, over time, Saddam has
grown more savvy about public relations. Today, by carefully controlling press access, he
keeps his ethnic cleansing from international view. Indeed, to listen to many in the United
States and Europe, you’d think the main cause of suffering in Iraq today is not Saddam, but
the U.S.-led sanctions campaign against him. In the swelling towns of northern Iraq,
however, they know better.

Abdullah, 44, a married father of six, tells a typical story. He was an elementary school
teacher in the oil-rich city of Kirkuk, a veteran of the eight-year Iran-Iraq War, and a
conscript in the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait. One day last spring, several policemen and an
official from Saddam’s ruling Baath Party (which foments racism against Kurds and
other non-Arabs) pushed their way into his house without warning. They confiscated the
family's U.N. oil-for-food-program ration cards, then ordered Abdullah and his elderly
parents to accompany them to the security headquarters "for five minutes," while his wife
and six children waited at home.

When Iraqi security finally released him-not five minutes but one week later-they told
Abdullah that his parents would remain in jail until the entire family agreed to abandon their
home and property. Abdullah relented. Three weeks later, the family left, having lost their
house and two cars, not to mention the quarter-million Iraqi dinar bribe they paid police in
order to get back their U.N. ration cards (so they could get food when they arrived in the
northern Kurdish safe-haven).

Abdullah said his expulsion was due to "Saddam's oil strategy. He does not want any Kurds
in areas of oil wealth." The Iraqi dictator, it seems, suspects Kurds and Turkmans of
disloyalty and feels his country’s precious oil reserves would be safer surrounded by ethnic
Arabs. The expulsions have grown so frequent, Abdullah added, that "there is no Kurdish
family in Kirkuk who is not waiting for the knock on their door."

Many Kurds have no choice but to wait. According to several refugees in Bardiqariman, a
tent city in the safe haven that held 1,660 people the day I visited, the Iraqi government no
longer allows Kurds to hold good jobs unless they reregister their ethnicity as Arab. Some
Kurds try to do just that, but it often doesn’t work. Saddam’s henchmen still cleanse them
from oil-rich areas, but, in an ironic nod to their assumed identity, many are banished not to
the Kurdish north but to non-oil-producing areas in the Arab south. I asked one family in the
northern town of Kalar how they got there. After I pointed out a few discrepancies in their
accounts, they admitted, embarrassed, that they had tried to change their identity to Arab but
were expelled anyway. Torture isn’t widespread, but it isn’t exactly unheard of either.

Qasim, 57, told me how security police snatched him and his family from their house in
Khanaqin, then savagely beat him in jail while his wife and daughters sat in the adjacent cell.
After one particularly harsh beating, Qasim's daughter Bisma explained, blood oozed from
her father's ears; he has been deaf ever since. Other families tell similar stories.
Seventy-three-year-old Nadeema cares for her son, who suffers from brain damage_the result
of a severe beating by Iraqi officers in 1994 during a round-up of young Kurdish men.
Despite her family's subsequent expulsion to Sulaymaniyah in the north, she considers
herself lucky, explaining, "Most families in Khanaqin never saw their sons again."

And the abuse can also be more subtle. Ruhnak, a 37-year-old woman, told me that Iraqi
security officers arrested her and demanded she divorce her husband, whom they accused of
working against the government. When she refused, they expelled her four children from
school and told her they would stop her U.N. oil-for-food rations if she did not leave
Khanaqin. She now lives in the city of Kalar across the border in the safe haven.

According to Zahir Shukur Bapir, head of the governing Patriotic Union of Kurdistan’s
Displaced Persons Bureau in Darbandikhan, the capital of the Kurdish-controlled section of
the Kirkuk governorate, "Every governorate [under Saddam’s control] has an Office of
Peoples' Issues from where they order expulsions." An emerging paper trail backs up his
claim. In one two-year-old document, recently smuggled into the safe-haven, one of
Saddam's governors issued detailed expulsion instructions, attaching a list of 1,380 people to
be expelled over the course of three months. Separately, the September 19, 2000, edition of
the official Iraqi newspaper Sawt al-Ta'amim (Voice of Nationalization) reported the
distribution of 10,000 plots of confiscated land to members of the Iraqi military and security
forces. Saddam's government quickly pulled the paper from newsstands, but dissidents had
already sent a few copies to the north.

Life for the Kurds expelled to tent cities in northern Iraq is bleak: Temperatures exceed 100
degrees during the summer, then fall below freezing in the winter. Drinking water is scarce.
Most displaced persons say they want to return home but cannot do so while Saddam
remains in power. Most of the refugees think Saddam views the Bush administration’s
ongoing effort to soften the sanctions regime as a sign of weakness. And, as they know all
too well, Saddam usually responds to weakness with aggression. Asked about returning
home, Muna, a recent arrival from Khanaqin, referred to Saddam's legendary chemical
weapons attack in 1988: "We are too afraid of another Anfal," she said. Perhaps the Bush
administration should be as well.

Michael Rubin, a Carnegie Council fellow and visiting scholar at The Washington Institute
for Near East Policy, recently returned from nine months in northern Iraq.
----------------------------------------