The
Kurdistan Observer
www.kurdistanobserver.com
Groups Seek Attention at Racism Meet
DURBAN, South Africa (AP) - Some of the less powerful victims of discrimination
say their
causes are not being addressed at the world conference on racism, which
has focused on
Israel and slavery reparations.
As delegates try to hammer out compromise language for the final declaration
to prevent the
European Union from joining the United States and Israel in pulling
out of the conference, a
less-watched effort had been under way to draw up a list of the victims
of discrimination.
Many groups were fighting to get on the list - including Kurds in Turkey
and the
untouchables in India - but say that they have no country to champion
their cause and thus
no voice on the declaration drafting committees.
``This conference, when it comes to Kurds and many others, is itself
a conference of
discrimination,'' said Bakhtiar Amin, a Kurd trying vainly to get his
people mentioned in the
conference's final document. ``They are selective and unfair in their
approach to many
victims of suffering.''
However, the group debating who would be on the list reached a compromise
late Thursday
not to draw up a list at all. It was still debating whether to expand
what grounds for
discrimination would be recognized by international law, said Arturo
Hernandez Basave, a
Mexican diplomat mediating the talks.
Turkey does not recognize its 12 million Kurds as a minority and views
Kurdish cultural
identity as a threat to the Turkish state. Turkish troops have fought
a 15-year war against
Kurdish rebels in the country's southeast. Some 37,000 people have
died as a result of the
conflict.
Dalits, also known as India's untouchable caste, worry that the paragraph
that deals with
discrimination ``on the basis of work and descent'' - a U.N. euphemism
for caste - will be
removed at India's behest.
India's minister of state for foreign affairs, Omar Abdullah, said his
country strongly opposed
even the ``work and descent'' wording.
Condemning the caste system would equate ``casteism with racism, which
makes India a
racist country, which we are not,'' he said.
Canada and the European Union want to add protection on the basis of
language and
religion, while African and Asian delegates want to stick to currently
accepted grounds of
race, skin color, descent and national or ethnic origin.
``Many delegations want to include other forms, such as age, sexual
orientation, HIV/AIDS
status and economic status,'' Hernandez said. ``Africa and Asia say
that will expand the
scope so that everyone will be considered a victim, and therefore laws
against racism will be
diluted.''
Other areas of the conference's draft declaration are also being challenged.
Gay groups are angry that references to discrimination based on sexual
orientation are still
under attack.
Before the conference, indigenous peoples had waged a successful battle
over an ``s,''
demanding they be described as ``indigenous peoples'' instead of ``indigenous
people.''
They felt that as peoples they would be recognized as distinct groups
with the right to self
determination, rather than simply a collection of people, said Juana
Majel, executive officer
of the National Congress of American Indians.
Now they are worried the ``s'' might be dropped and are furious over
the likely inclusion of
two caveat paragraphs that say their rights are subject to the power
of the countries where
they live, Majel said.
``That is unacceptable,'' she said. ``We are sovereign nations.''
Proposed text demanding protection for asylum seekers also appears to
have been eliminated
and activists worry that the only two paragraphs regarding refugees
still in the document
were about to be watered down or dropped completely.
``It leaves you wondering whether governments really care about the
plight of refugees,
given the scale of the refugee problem worldwide,'' said Rachael Reilly,
refugee policy
director at Human Rights Watch. ``There is a vacuum of moral leadership.''
------------------------------
|